• November 14Operation ELF coming up in December

  • November 14Frosh/Soph Plays 12/8-12/9

  • November 10Girls Volleyball win 4A state championship

The student news site of Wahlert Catholic High School

The Gleaner

Filed under Opinion, Sports

Taking a knee: NFL players protest

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






by Sophia Shubatt

Of the Gleaner

 

Athletes across the nation, from high schoolers to players in the NFL and MLB, have been taking a knee during the National Anthem. Many fans are outraged, many are supportive and many don’t know what to think.

The first step to understanding the issue is to really look into why these athletes are doing what they’re doing. The protests started in 2016 with Colin Kaepernick, of the 49ers, when he began kneeling during the anthem to bring awareness to police brutality and the general inequality that people of color experience in America.

“I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color,” said Kaepernick to NFL.com.

These protests have gained traction in the last few weeks, most notably with players in the NFL, with many teams and individuals taking part. The backlash is substantial and many fans are upset, even booing the players involved, but teams seem to be standing by their players, making statements of support.

Chicago Bears Chairman George H. McCaskey made the following statement:

“The Chicago Bears are proud to support our players, coaches and all members of our organization to bring peace and unity together through football. What makes this the greatest country in the world are the liberties it was founded upon and the freedom to express oneself in a respectful and peaceful manner. Through important dialogue with our players and team, this divisive political situation has unified our franchise for the present and the future.”

President Trump responded to the protests by saying, “Wouldn’t you love to see one of these NFL owners, when somebody disrespects our flag, to say, ‘Get that son of a b**** off the field right now, out, he’s fired.” While many of his supporters agreed with him, Trump’s statements seemed to serve as a catalyst because players responded by locking arms and entire teams knelt together in solidarity.

The United States actually has set guidelines for how to show respect for the flag (US Flag Code) that have been in place since Flag Day of 1923, but it makes no mention of standing or kneeling and whether or not either is unacceptable.

The code originally enforced penalties for disrespect to the flag, but the Supreme Court ruled that these punishments restricted Americans’ First Amendment right to free speech. While these guidelines are not punishable by law, they are generally still respected and looked to by government officials.

Interestingly, the Flag Code does have rules that are broken every day, but nobody even knows such rules exist. For example, it is considered disrespectful to wear the flag as a piece of clothing or to use it in advertisements of any kind other than for those  of the military.

Those who are upset about the protests are angry because they believe kneeling shows a lack of respect for the soldiers who fought for our freedom.“To me, standing for the National Anthem is a chance to thank the people who fought and are still fighting to keep our country strong,” said Maria Molo, ‘18. “I agree with these players’ message, but I think there are better and more respectful ways to go about protesting.”

Molo points out that, with all the resources these players have, there are much more effective ways to get their message out to the community. “It just seems like everyone is talking about the controversial kneeling instead of the actual problem of inequality.”

Wahlert’s own football team has mixed feelings on the issue. “It’s hard to say. I think there is a huge issue of inequality in our country, but I don’t agree with the way they’re going about it,” said Eli Berthel, ‘18.

Putting aside the controversy, kneeling during the national anthem is a peaceful protest, a right protected under the First Amendment. Perhaps, instead of being angry or supportive of the kneeling itself, Americans should look at their own lives and really try to solve the problems that the kneeling represents.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

2 Comments

2 Responses to “Taking a knee: NFL players protest”

  1. Hunter McDonald on October 4th, 2017 12:25 pm

    Don’t agree with this article. Clear democratic bias shown by schubatt. This is disrespectful no way around it. I don’t care what the amendments say. The anthem is a time of unity for our nation, shouldn’t be differed to a time to focus on the Black Lives Matter movement…. It’s a distraction and makes for great democratic news #ClintonNewsNetwork

    [Reply]

  2. James Miller on October 4th, 2017 12:30 pm

    If the goal of the kneeling athletes was to get people to talk about the issues, they’ve both succeeded and failed. Certainly everybody is talking about the kneeling … but not everybody understands why it’s happening or what it’s a protest against. Many Americans think it’s a protest against the anthem itself, or against the flag, or against the troops, or against the entire country. That’s not true, but whose fault is it that the protest’s critics don’t understand the protest? Is it the protesters’ fault, or the fault of the press for consistently doing a poor job of covering the protests?

    [Reply]

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




*

The student news site of Wahlert Catholic High School
Taking a knee: NFL players protest